“If you have a substantive comment, please provide more detail.” | Re: Sure

Example 1: Pediatric Practice is Opposite The Published Scientific Evidence On Early Vaccine Safety

ChaoticPharma

September 23, 2014 at 11:14 pm
Reblogged this on Chaos Theory and Human Pharmacology and commented:
1- I’m sorry but your arguments are all the opposite to the evidence
2- Your viewpoints are supported by the repetitive use of several fallacies.
3- Are you trying to create a debate solely with a survey plus an incorrect appraisal of the evidence?

natphilosopher
September 23, 2014 at 11:23 pm
If you have a substantive comment, please provide more detail. I don’t know why you say any of those three things.

---

Sure, I can explain more if you think my previous comment was not “substantive”.

I will repeat each one the three points & also add a short explanation. In addition, it is up to you support your comments with evidence and avoid the use of fallacies (2nd point – below).

1. your arguments are all the opposite to the evidence

– http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=MMR

– MMR – Completed – ClinicalTrials.gov | Search Date: September 24, 2014

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1drA2F0bCNxOWG_GvQ8XmnkopEqrH484f1q1KeUJkCL8/edit#gid=771221639

– How many unpublished or published? http://goo.gl/cc5BnW

2. One example (please identify others by yourself): “cherry picking”
Please let me know if you need a more comprehensive evaluation of fallacies used to support your viewpoint.

3. Do you have unpublished research data (i.e., evidence) to support your statements (I will quote you below)?

Please let me know if you need a more substantive comment.

Best wishes,

Jorge

---

“Our survey has found that not only is there no proof of vaccine safety in the peer-reviewed literature, the overwhelming preponderance of the evidence suggests that early vaccines are causing damage. It’s past time for medical practice to take note.” – Quote from: Example 1: Pediatric Practice is Opposite The Published Scientific Evidence On Early Vaccine Safety (response is also available in this post)